Talk:Athena Asamiya

Spillover Gallery
I guess...? Sake neko 20:56, 19 January 2009 (UTC)

The main page can handle many illustrations. Look at the Ryu page for reference. Allow me to add more artworks to the main page so that this wikia will be comparable to Capcom's. We don't have a spillover sprite gallery so we don't need a hidden one for illustrations. It's useful and fun to look at them and informative when the game and artist is displayed below it. Don't ruin the fun! Wikia should be fun for readers to read! :) BurnsBogard 01:54, 25 August 2009 (UTC)
 * Haha, that's true! Well, I'll forgive it since it's Athena. :) Sake neko 05:52, 25 August 2009 (UTC)
 * I don't mind it for sprites since they're smaller than the gallery thumbnails and don't take up nearly as much space. There's also the matter the most of the time the character's appearance doesn't really change, just the art style. The reasoning that "Capcom does it!" doesn't really seem much of a reason to me really. But in this case I guess it's ok since she changes outfits every almost every appearance anyways. Kyosei 22:46, 25 August 2009 (UTC)

There is no reason why we need to have only 8 images in the gallery. This isn't wikipedia where we need to keep things short. No one is going to look for more pictures in the discussion page. I'm going to start adding many more than 8 images to the other character galleries as well, even if they wear the same outfit. If other wikias can handle more than 8 images than this one can as well. BurnsBogard 13:05, 26 August 2009 (UTC)
 * It's mostly to limit it from becoming larger than the article itself eventually. Similar to a block of text, a block of images is not that much better unless that's the purpose of the page. Such as Gallery of The King of Fighters '98 Endings. I think that's what eventually would need to happen with these character galleries if we added every game appearance. Kyosei 22:01, 26 August 2009 (UTC)

This Ryu article doesn't look bad even though there are a lot of images. http://capcomdatabase.wikia.com/wiki/Ryu. I think it's fine if it's at the very end of the article and do you think the average reader of the SNK wikia would mind if there were a lot of illustrations? I think they'd love looking at how the characters have evolved throughout the years. I'll comply with your wishes for now though and add more images to characters that are seriously lacking in them. Just think it over. Thanks! BurnsBogard 12:26, 27 August 2009 (UTC)
 * Ryu's gallery is ok until you realize that it makes up for over half of his current article. I'd rather character articles to focus on the character itself in terms of information that people wouldn't necessary know (as a good portion of info we put up here is in Japanese only) rather than a "ooh look at the pretty pictures" gallery. It's easy to find a picture. There's other off-site websites that do the same thing and better than wikia anyways. Then there's also the matter of deciding what appearances to include in the gallery. If we were to include every outfit she's ever worn in every game, it'd be much bigger. There's at least, off of the top of my head, 20-30 we haven't included from mobile games alone. Limiting it to 8 keeps it from looking like we're favoring one character over another as well.


 * Besides as you notice with the character sprites we didn't actually add every single one from every game appearance either. Most of the them are just re-used over various games anyways. The only time a new sprite is really added is when it's either a) re-animated or b) a different sprite/appearance altogether. The gallery mostly reflected the same thing as well for appearances. Kyosei 18:57, 27 August 2009 (UTC)